Table of Contents

After protesters drive Gregory Bovino offstage, Rutgers gets free speech right

Campus police cleared the room after protesters disrupted the former Trump border official’s speech, allowing the event to continue.
Gregory Bovino with border patrol agents

Tom Baker/Associated Press

Then-U.S. Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino arrives as protesters gather outside the Bishop Henry Whipple Federal Building in Minneapolis on Jan. 8, 2026. (AP Photo/Tom Baker)

Rutgers University has a rough record when it comes to free speech. But today, it deserves some praise. While politicians, student groups, and commentators spent the day arguing about “platforming” a controversial campus event, Rutgers got it right.

The lead-up

Ahead of Monday’s Rutgers Republicans event — a speech and Q&A with former U.S. Border Patrol Commander Gregory Bovino — a petition calling for its cancellation had more than 1,600 signatures. The petition urged Rutgers to cancel the speech, arguing that Bovino’s presence on campus would create an intimidating environment for students.

Rutgers didn’t give in. On Friday, Nov. 13, a Rutgers spokesperson defended students’ right to hold the event: “As a public university, Rutgers is committed to protecting freedom of expression, even when views expressed may be controversial or generate disagreement.” The university confirmed that there would be an area for protesters to assemble the night of the event.

UK police confront protesters

UK police arrest hundreds more peaceful protesters under anti-terror law

UK police arrest hundreds more peaceful protesters under anti-terror laws, while a Georgian journalist is jailed again for mocking politicians.

Read More

Had one of the country’s worst universities in the College Free Speech Rankings (a disastrous 257th out of 261 schools) finally figured out its First Amendment responsibilities? Given Rutgers’ history of canceling speakers due to community uproar, skepticism was warranted.

The controversy

On Monday, Nov. 16, New Jersey Gov. Mikie Sherrill criticized the Rutgers Republicans’ event, saying that giving Bovino a “platform” was “the wrong decision.” To her credit, the governor never called for a cancellation, and she committed to protecting “the safety of everyone and the rights enshrined in our Constitution.”

Elected officials obviously have the same rights as the rest of us to make strong political statements, even directed at student clubs. But they should defend the expressive rights of those they oppose just as strongly. Had the governor used (or threatened to use) the power of her office to stop the event or discipline the club, that would have been a First Amendment problem. Thankfully, her post didn’t do that.

The Rutgers University Democrats also released a statement Monday condemning the club for inviting Bovino. They claimed his record “poses a threat to the safety of students” and that no one who oversaw his Border Patrol operations should be presented as “a respected voice.” 

The test

Bovino’s speech appears to have started as planned. But just minutes after he began talking, protesters disrupted the event. Bovino was quickly escorted out of the room and police gave the protesters a few minutes to disperse. 

For a moment, it looked as if the hecklers won. 

But Rutgers went ahead and did its job. Police removed the disruptive protesters from the room, and just a few minutes later, Bovino returned to the stage to finish the event.

Commentary from the Rutgers Republicans suggests that the university staff restricted access to the event following the disruptions. FIRE is reviewing these allegations. But compared to some of the disasters we’ve seen when it comes to controversial events, this one has to go in the “win” column for free expression.

Protest isn’t permission to silence

Predictably, folks across the internet went back and forth claiming their preferred side as the ones truly exercising their First Amendment rights. For example, internet commentator Brian Krassenstein shared a video of the disruptors interrupting Bovino’s remarks and wrote on X, “As a proud Rutgers alumnus, I’m glad to see students exercising their First Amendment rights and refusing to remain silent.”

He’s half right. Those students had every right to protest Bovino and condemn everything he stands for. What they didn’t have the right to do was derail someone else’s event and prevent the invited speaker from being heard. 

That’s a heckler’s veto. The First Amendment protects your right to speak, but it doesn’t give you the right to make sure no one else can. 

Frederick Douglass, who famously wrote about being the victim of a heckler’s veto in A Plea for Free Speech in Boston, understood this well: “To suppress free speech is a double wrong. It violates the rights of the hearer as well as those of the speaker.” 

Copies of French writer Michel Houellebecq's novel "Serotonine" are displayed in a book store, in Paris, Friday, Jan. 4, 2019. (AP Photo/Thibault Camus)

Prosecuting Michel Houellebecq will not make France safer, but it will be less free

Houellebecq is facing a judge-led investigation for "incitement to discrimination" for comments he made in a 2022 magazine interview.

Read More

To her credit, Gov. Sherrill clearly articulated the proper counter to an event one might disagree with in her statement. She argued that attendees should use the opportunity to challenge and question Bovino directly about his record.

Learning and inquiry are at the heart of higher education. Universities exist so students and faculty can pursue knowledge, challenge beliefs, and debate ideas. Nobody can learn from or challenge Bovino if he isn’t allowed to make his beliefs heard to the willing audience.

So, kudos to Rutgers. Rutgers said it was going to do the right thing on Friday, but it remained to be seen when the protests came if the university would stand its ground. And it did.

One night doesn’t clear years of issues. But progress deserves recognition. On Monday night, Rutgers got it right.

Recent Articles

Get the latest free speech news and analysis from FIRE.

Share