Case Overview

FIRE Victory

Following the footsteps of other states, West Virginia passed “Daniel’s Law,” with stated aims of protecting the privacy of judges, prosecutors and public defenders, and law enforcement officers. Daniel’s Law allows those officials to sue anyone who “discloses” their home address or unpublished telephone number without permission, if “a reasonable person would believe that providing such information would expose another to harassment or risk of harm to life or property.” The statute defines “disclose” broadly, sweeping in publishing, providing, or disseminating by any means a covered address or phone number–and applies even if the government itself makes that information publicly available. 

Michael Jackson, a retired law enforcement officer, filed a class action lawsuit against several entities who routinely publish information Daniel’s Law covers. The U.S. District Court for the Northern District for West Virginia dismissed the lawsuit, rightly holding Daniel’s Law is a content-based regulation of speech that fails the rigorous strict scrutiny standard vital to protecting speech against the dangers of content-based restrictions on speech. 

FIRE filed an amicus brief in support of the defendants in Jackson v. Thomas Reuters America Corporation, and affirming the district court’s decision. FIRE’s brief explains the importance of applying strict scrutiny to content-based statutes like Daniel’s Law, and the dangers to free expression that can arise when courts do not keep the starch in the constitutional standards that protect against government censorship.

FIRE’s brief also highlights how journalists and ordinary citizens alike often share address and phone numbers of judges and law enforcement officials when commenting on important public issues, from sharing stories about those officials using personal phones to engage in misconduct to revealing that a police chief lives far away from the people he is obligated to protect and serve. Expansive content-based statutes like Daniel’s Law will chill that important speech, opening speakers up to retaliatory lawsuits for speaking out about government officials’ conduct.

On October 27, 2026, a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit unanimously affirmed the district court’s ruling that West Virginia’s Daniel’s Law violates the First Amendment. The court agreed that the law’s restrictions on publishing the home addresses and telephone numbers of certain public officials are content-based regulations of protected speech, subject to strict scrutiny. Although the court noted the state has a compelling interest in protecting public officials from harm, it held that the law is not the least restrictive means of achieving that goal, because it imposes liability without requiring publishers to know they have disclosed protected information or providing an opportunity to remove it after receiving notice. The court emphasized that such sweeping restrictions risk chilling constitutionally protected speech. The decision is a significant victory for the First Amendment principles FIRE defended in its amicus brief, reaffirming that even well-intentioned laws must respect constitutional protections for public debate and the free flow of information.

Share