Table of Contents
So to Speak Transcript: Trump vs. the Smithsonian: Who controls America's history? w/ Jessica Dickinson Goodman
Note: This is an unedited rush transcript. Please check any quotations against the audio recording.
Nico Perrino: Hey, folks. Nico here. Just a reminder that my book, Free Speech Generation, is now available for pre-order wherever books are sold. And as I announced at the top of the last episode, we are running a special pre-order incentive through publication date. That is January 19th. If you pre-order a copy of the book in any format, we will mail you a free limited-edition FIRE t-shirt by early February. All you need to do after you pre-order the book is fill out the short form at the website. That website URL is fire.org/freespeechgeneration.
Again, that's fire.org/freespeechgeneration. And that's where you can provide your proof of purchase, your shirt size, and delivery address, and so, it should be simple enough; buy a book, fill out the short form, and get a free shirt. As I have mentioned before, pre-orders are super important for the success of any book, so if you are at all interested in checking out the book, I hope you'll consider pre-ordering a copy. Yes, audiobook pre-orders count and will be available soon. And sorry, the offer is only available to United States residents. Okay. Now, onto the show.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: The idea that I should walk into a museum and see only human perfection is idolism. It's idolizing people.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Or it’s propaganda.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: And it becomes propaganda.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Particularly, when the state orders it.
[Video Begins]
Martin Luther King, Jr.: Somewhere I read of the freedom of speech.
[Video Ends]
Nico Perrino: You're listening to So to Speak: The Free Speech Podcast brought to you by FIRE, the Foundation For Individual Rights and Expression. All right, folks. Welcome back to So to Speak: The Free Speech Podcast where every other week we take an uncensored look at the world of free expression through the law, philosophy, and stories that define your right to free speech. I'm your host, Nico Perino. The Smithsonian Institution in Washington, D.C. is the world's largest museum, education, and research complex.
Over the past year, hundreds of ordinary Americans have been photographing its exhibits, not because they're enthusiastic tourists, but because they fear those exhibits could be altered, or even disappear, because of political pressure. Nearly 180 years after Congress created the Smithsonian, the White House is trying to change how the nation's museums tell the American story. It has demanded reviews of exhibits, threatened federal funding, targeted museum leaders, and ordered government signs posted outside the National Museum of American History warning visitors that the museum is ideologically biased.
In response, a grassroots organization called Citizen Historians for the Smithsonian has mobilized hundreds of volunteers to document every Smithsonian exhibit in Washington, D.C. and New York City. So far, they've compiled an archive of more than 73,000 photos and videos. Joining me today to discuss the administration's attacks on, or reforms of, the Smithsonian, depending on your perspective, of course, is Jessica Dickinson Goodman. She is the co-founder of Citizen Historians for the Smithsonian. Jessica, welcome on to the show.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Thank you so much for having me.
Nico Perrino: Let's start with your background. What's your interest in the Smithsonian? Where’s that come from?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I've been going, sir, a long time. My partner and I used to meet in D.C. every other weekend when we were in college. He was at William & Mary, I was at Carnegie Mellon, and D.C. split the difference. And I'm not a museum studies professional. Public history isn't my main area of expertise, but I love the museums. And back in August 2025, after the White House Domestic Policy Council sent out a letter to the Smithsonian leadership, like you were mentioning, demanding lists of exhibits for them to review and detailed what they called wall texts to review, a couple of the professors at Georgetown wrote to us and said, “Hey, people in the history department. We're gonna start photographing. What would you like to do?”
And I sometimes have a very strategic approach to what work I do, and sometimes it's a gut instinct that this is something that I can do and be helpful in.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: When I got the email. I thought, “Oh. I know how to structure that. I've been a campaign manager. I've worked in tech. Like this will be fine.” I wrote back a campaign plan and they said, “Great. Do you wanna go do it?” And I said, “Sure.” Yeah. I'm in two masters. I have one kid. At the time, I was 10 weeks pregnant, but it was work that needed doing. I love the Smithsonian museums. I love museums in general. That's the thing that's in common. Our volunteers come from across the political spectrum, from across the nation.
We do have our main focus of documenting what's here, but we also have folks documenting traveling exhibits in Wyoming, Indiana, Georgia, as well as folks who are even documenting in exhibit tours in Africa, or in the UK, or the Netherlands.
Nico Perrino: And the concern here is that the pressure from the administration is gonna change what the professional expertise from the curators, or whatever, who are putting on these exhibits, would do ordinarily.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: Create either a chilling effect or an outright censorship of their exhibits.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. There’s definitely a chilling effect that's already been reported. Kelsey Ables at The Atlantic has done interviews, and I know, and probably, you do, too, when folks at the Smithsonian folks are trying to keep their heads down. Ada Palmer on your podcast talked about that.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: That's how censorship works. Right? It's never gonna be that Vince Haley, who's the head of the White House Domestic Policy Council, is gonna walk into Air and Space and pull down the banner of Katherine Johnson, who is, obviously, a computer and there's a wonderful movie written about her and about her fellow computers in the Apollo Program and about the hard work that they did. But there's a banner of her there and that could be really offensive to somebody who doesn't want the work of computers, the work of black women, to be included in the story of air and space.
Realistically, that's not how censorship is gonna happen. Like most abusive systems, censorship does most of its work in the minds of its victims in my experience. The people who are sitting in committee meetings in rooms trying to decide, “Will I propose my best idea? Will I go into the archive to look for a hard story? Or am I gonna go and look at the July 4th White House Domestic Policy Council report, which had a list of exhibits they wish the Smithsonian would put on instead and do one of those?”
Nico Perrino: And this is what I had referred to earlier as the chilling effect.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Exactly.
Nico Perrino: Right? It chills what you might otherwise do or say because you know, or have seen –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Uh-huh.
Nico Perrino: – or expect to get censored as a result of it.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Exactly.
Nico Perrino: All you need to do is make an example of –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: – one exhibit or one museum leader.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Exactly. Or be publicly humiliated as they did in the White House Domestic Policy Council report from this July. They, by name, called out individual mid-level staffers and went through their records and found quotes that they didn't like, and then, published it from the White House, the place where the Situation Room is.
Nico Perrino: Has there been anything that has been taken down as of yet or just threatened?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Good question. The National Portrait Gallery removed all of the wall text next to the presidents, all living presidents’ portraits, and then, they've rewritten them.
Nico Perrino: Kind of like Trump did at the White House.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: Or maybe not to that extent?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. Not. I think that the rewrites are, basically, when I've seen them, they're fair. They're rewrites that are focused on the CVs, but that reaction, there wasn't any published or planned reason to take down everyone's wall text other than the president was very upset about his.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: They didn't replace Joe Biden's portrait with an auto pen.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: No.
Nico Perrino: No.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: No.
Nico Perrino: But there was something that happened with President Trump's portrait. Right? Didn't it reference the impeachments in January 6th?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And it referenced his incredibly powerful movement and it referenced a huge range of things that he'd done. We have the text up on our website. If you go to citizenhistorians.org and click on exhibit changes, you can read the original text and the modified text. We don't have the money to shade or hide anything we're doing. Anytime we identify a problem, we put it on the website in the full text so people can decide for themselves.
Nico Perrino: Is the reference to the impeachments and the January 6th riots, are those still there?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: No.
Nico Perrino: They're not there.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Not that I saw.
Nico Perrino: But there was?
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: But I'd have to double check.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. Yeah. Sure. And folks can go and check that online –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: – if they want to. But a lot of the concern centers around the National Museum for American History. Right?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. And so, in the August 2025 letter that they sent, they made a list in order of all the museums that they wanted to go after; American History, African-American History and Culture, National Museum of Native American History, or American Indian History. Obviously, the museum title uses the older term.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: National Portrait Gallery is at the bottom, but this administration is not necessarily a check it off in order kind of administration.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. Yeah. And obviously, probably has concerns or interests, I should say, in how the president is portrayed.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Uh-huh. Well, I'm excited to see what his actual official portrait is because he never turned it in.
Nico Perrino: Oh. There's no official portrait from [inaudible – crosstalk] [00:09:01].
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: There’s a photograph, and he doesn't like the photograph, but he didn't approve the official portrait that he had done back in the first term.
Nico Perrino: Oh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: We don't actually know what it is.
Nico Perrino: Oh. Interesting. And so, it was that photo that had –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Uh-huh. That he doesn't like, apparently, but they wouldn't turn one into the National Portrait Gallery, and they didn't want to insult his supporters, or just people who wanted to see a picture of the president, by having nothing.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: But he wouldn't give them anything, and so, I think they picked the one that, I don't know. I'm not in the room and I'm not a curator there, but they're not trying to embarrass people. They're trying to pick a picture they like. And I guess they guessed wrong. Sort of hard to guess what this one.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. What photos people like. I've seen photos of myself that I haven't liked that other people have said are great, so you never know.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And it was taken in the White House in the Oval Office. He's looking into the camera. It's not some sneak peek. It's the one where he's sitting there with his fist on the table glaring, but.
Nico Perrino: Oh. Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Apparently, he doesn't like it.
Nico Perrino: There was some other concerns surrounding the national parks, too. Right?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. That's a really, to me, a really sad story. Save Our Signs is a group that has been doing a lot of this work in the national parks. In the president's March 2025 executive order, he orders the Department of the Interior to take down information that disparages Americans living or dead. And of course, disparage is a really complicated word to manage. Right? How do you write about while showing respect to somebody who may have done something complicated? To me, respecting a historical figure is telling the truth about them.
Nico Perrino: Sure.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Not shading it or hiding it.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: But that's clearly not what he was articulating in that order, and the National Park Service employees followed both the spirit and the letter of that letter from the White House, that executive order. They've taken down more than 100 signs in the last year and a half. There's a Guardian article. You can see photos of it. Save Our Signs lets you see the before and afters if they are able to capture it. There's this one image that gets to me. It's in Arcadia National Park in Maine where sometime they took the old sign away and replaced it with no note saying anything had changed.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: But this one, for whatever reason, they didn't have the budget or they couldn't change it, so they sawed it off of the fence. Now, there's just two mangled posts sitting there that used to have a sign that referenced climate change, and now, there's nothing. And at least to me, that is what we're trying to avoid at the Smithsonian.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. Kind of reminds me of the Internet Archive. For example, Save Our Signs and the Citizen Historians for the Smithsonian. What you guys are doing is trying to document how things once looked.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. And in a real life way back machine.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. Right. Exactly. A real life way back machine. I want to ask now about the challenges of running a museum.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Uh-huh.
Nico Perrino: Is there a way to determine how history should be told? Right. Like what a curator decides should go in an exhibit is gonna be a judgment call. Now, you have professional ethics and guidance kind of bounding it, but at the end of the day, it's still a judgment call. Right? Like in your mind, how should these museums operate and how should they determine what goes in, what comes out, and what changes? Presumably, once something is put up, it doesn't stay that way forever. There is a decision, often, at some point, to alter or change an exhibit.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. I'm not a museum studies professional and I've never run one professionally, but I will say, as a guiding light, I think a lot about the Statue of Liberty. We talked about our kids before. I have a nearly four-year-old. At the Arlington Library book sale, he got a little book about the Statue of Liberty. And I was trying to figure out what was odd about it. And I realized it's bronze. When it was put up, it was very shiny, and very sparkly, and bronze colored. And if you ask me to draw it today, I would make it green because it's oxidized. Right?
Nico Perrino: Yeah. Right. They are sitting atop the ocean.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Exactly. And over time, as things age and undergo different forces around them and different amounts of maintenance or non-maintenance, our understandings of them change. That's normal. The National Museum of American History was originally a technology and innovation museum that they've then rebranded in the ‘80s to the National Museum of American History, but their collection is a lot of inventor stuff. Their curators go and look at what they have, and then, figure out what they can say about it.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And they go through the literature, the historiography, to use a super fancy word for just the study of the history itself, and then, they have to come up with a way to summarize each of these objects in about 75 words. Usually, between like a fourth to a ninth-grade reading level. That's tough.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: That's a tough one. Of course, it was one of the things that's been hard because I like to be both principled and accurate when objecting to what the White House is doing. The signs that the president wants to spend $84,000.00 on putting outside the National Museum of American History, part of the claim is that this museum contains inaccurate information.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh. And that's the claim that will be on the signs.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: If they ever get them up.
Nico Perrino: That they're biased. Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Exactly.
Nico Perrino: They've announced that they want to put them up, but they haven't put them out.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. Exactly. And the answer, part of me, which is not the most not the most activist-y, but very historian-y of me, is, of course, there's inaccuracies. Like, it's made by humans. Everything has an inaccuracy that they then have to fix in it. The Statue of Liberty book has inaccuracies in it because it's written for my four-year-old, or my almost four-year-old. As a shorter answer, when a museum is seeking to tell the best truth that they can for the broadest public that comes, that's the work itself. And if the Heritage Foundation had put out the report, you would not hear me complaining about it.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: If a civil society group came and put out this report from this past summer criticizing over 162 pages, referencing the director by name 212 times, that criticism of the Smithsonian, people should criticize institutions that use taxpayer dollars. They're supposed to. The wall builders out in Dallas, Fort Worth, who do a lot of critiquing of how modern museums manage the Revolutionary War period.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Absolutely. That's civil society. They're supposed to make these critiques. The problem comes in for me is when the White House does it. I don't think it's appropriate for the White House to be criticizing, or very directively trying to tell people how to understand American history.
Nico Perrino: Well, the challenge is that this was an institution that was created by the government and act of Congress. Right? Its Board of Regents has the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court on it, members of Congress on it. I believe it receives something like 60 some-odd percent of its budget. Should the government not have a say in what goes in and what's working, what's not working?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Well, it structurally has a say. It has six members of Congress, the vice president, and the chief justice.
Nico Perrino: You're saying the White House shouldn't get involved.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And the White House.
Nico Perrino: Okay. Is there no member of the White House?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: The vice president’s there.
Nico Perrino: The vice president is there.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: Okay. But this is –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: They have a voice.
Nico Perrino: They have a voice.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: But they should not be criticizing it from the White House Domestic Policy Council. They should not be putting up signs that direct people away from the museum, which is what the president in the July 24th executive order requests to be on the signs, or orders to be on the signs, is directing them away from the museum and towards alternate sources of information.
Nico Perrino: If they were doing a lot of the same stuff, but through the channel of the Board of Regents, for example, you would have less objection to it or no objection to it?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: If it's Congress doing it, Congress is the one that appropriates the money. They're supposed to be critical. That's their job. I want them to be critical of where sources of money goes. And when they go and bring people up before Congress to testify, or most of these conversations happen not in front of all the cameras, that's part of taking government money. I used to work my first job in D.C. was at an anti-human trafficking nonprofit and we got a million dollars a year to run the National Human Trafficking Hotline, and the Department of Health and Human Services would routinely reedit documents that we put out under that grant to remove references to trafficking of LGBTQ folks, because that particular grant monitor did not believe that LGBTQ folks could be trafficked.
That sucks, but it is part of taking government money to have those dialogues back with your grant monitor. And that's the frame that I think is valuable. Some people, including, I would argue, possibly folks in the White House, didn't really understand what a trust instrumentality is, which is what the Smithsonian is. It's not an executive agency and it's not a project of Congress. It's a legally unique thing called a trust instrumentality.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And some of the people who work at the Smithsonian are federal employees. Some are paid for out of trust funds, not like the kind that people at Georgetown have. Trust funds. Right?
Nico Perrino: Not the kind that I wish I had.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. And that I do not have, and neither will my children. But that's, I mean, that's legally complicated. Right? But that's why the Smithsonian has been able to avoid bending its employee speech to fit the whims of this particular White House in a way that universities, the Department of Defense, major law firms, and the National Park Service have not been able to –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: – stay consistent with their messaging as they were prior to this president, but the Smithsonian has, which I think shows how effective that design was because –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Well, those designs are under pressure. Right? Like the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. I don't know if it's a similar design to this, but it's supposed to be not really under the control of the executive branch, not really under the control of Congress. It's like this unique thing that was created by Congress so that it could be independent, but the Supreme Court has recently said that these sorts of independent institutions have really no place within our constitutional framework. We mean maybe a constitutional amendment to create them.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: They're kind of left in limbo and subject to the pressures from the executive branch, which executes the laws passed by Congress, or at least that's how it's working out.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: Whether one thinks it should work out that way is a matter of interpretation.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Well, and this is paraphrasing something you'd said on an earlier podcast, but I think a really important political corollary of the Golden Rule is never do unto others which you do not wish to have done to you next time.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: If people would really like the Smithsonian and these institutions to not sway wildly every time there's a new occupant of the White House, it behooves all of us to allow them to remain independent. Can you imagine somebody who occupies the position that President Trump occupies on the spectrum, but on the mirror side –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: – putting out reports criticizing every single thing in the museum, highlighting individual staff members by name. I don't think somebody would do that. This is a really unique form of using the White House power to try and shape culture and shape memory, but that thought should scare anyone that wants to misuse this power this way.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. Well, if I'm steel-manning the other side, and I think I know how to because I get a lot of these comments from our listeners.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: They would say the other side doesn't need to do it because the people who would do it are already within the institutions. The ideologues, excuse me, of the left are already there. And I read in a ProPublica report about one of the things that the museum was using to train its staff, and I'm reading here from the report. “Republican lawmakers criticized the museum for having trained staff using the “museums as a site for social action toolkit,” a 200-plus page roadmap on how to truly transform the museum space, which is linked with white supremacy, heteropatriarchy, abuse of labor, colonization, imperialist theft of art and artifacts, destruction or absencing of alternative ways of interpreting or reinterpreting art and artifacts, structural racism, and other impressions.”
It also notes that, “Representative Brandon Gill, a Texas Republican, noted that the toolkit that the museum used for staff training had referred to politeness as a feature of “white supremacy culture.”” The right is saying “This institution is already captured by the left.” All you have to do is look at their training materials. Remember, there was one controversy surrounding the signage at George Washington's home on Independence Mall outside Independence Hall, which focused on his use of slaves in the household rather than anything else you might say about the first president of the United States
And they'd say, you know, “The judgment that's being made here is left leaning, it's focusing on systems of oppression and victimization.” And while that's a part of the story, is it the part of the story that we should be focusing on in our museums, at our national monuments, or is it a part of the story that should be given as much emphasis as it's being given? And they're worried it's being given that much emphasis because the people who are in charge of it are ideologically predisposed to that.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And you mentioned this was a critique from the right.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And if the right wants to put out reports, like I said, the Heritage Foundation, wall builders, there's an entire infrastructure and ecosystem to put out reports making these critiques. My problem is when –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Is the process.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: – the White House does it.
Nico Perrino: It's the process.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I have no problem with a grand debate about how we should talk about these things. It's fun. It's fun talking about these things.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: How to do history, Yes.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: How to do history, how to think about it, how to talk about it with kids.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Because I think if we summed up the entire report, they have one section of the executive summary, which they write in D.C. They know most people don't read past the executive summary, but they have a summary of their core argument, which is that, in fact, speaking of the White House Domestic Policy Council, they say that warning signs should be put up at every entrance to the museum, to the American Museum. I got it. National Museum of American History.
Nico Perrino: I messed that up earlier.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. I know. It's a hard one.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: I said for American history or of American history.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I know. Exactly.
Nico Perrino: The American History Museum, for all intents and purposes.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Exactly. The American History Museum. The White House Domestic Policy Council report put out this statement as part of this report saying they wanted signs at every entrance to say the people who work in this museum don't want you to love your country.
Nico Perrino: That's a pretty grand claim.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: It's a pretty wild claim to me.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And to me, it's frustrating to have my patriotism called into question implicitly by my reaction to museum displays. It talks about how inappropriate it is to have a museum that children go to talk about the flaws of humans. And the thing is, and this is not unique to my religious background, but as a Christian, I think everyone's flawed. In theory, in theory, there's only one perfect person within the Christian framework, and that's not everybody's framework, which is totally fine, but the idea that I should walk into a museum and see only human perfection is idolism. It’s idolizing people.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Or it's propaganda.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: And it becomes propaganda.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Particularly, when the state orders it.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And that, to me, is pretty deeply troubling. The idea. But I keep going back. They have a section. They talk about kids a lot. They complain about how this museum isn't what they want to show their kids a lot. And I talk about these hard topics with my kids, even though they're small. There are ways to do it. There are ways to have these conversations. And I don't recognize the Americans that they say they're protecting. Most Americans I know are capable of hearing a bad thing and getting on with their day.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Are capable of learning that a person was imperfect and moving on with their day.
Nico Perrino: Well, it's empowering in a certain sense, the idea that you can be imperfect, yet, also do great things.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Aren’t we all?
Nico Perrino: That’s one of the reasons that Game of Thrones was such a popular TV show.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: Is that it showed the human imperfections of every single character.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: It wasn't a binary, all good, all bad story. Same with any good story. I mean, any good movie or television show.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And I don't want to do too many spoilers for Game of Thrones, but as long as my partner isn't listening, our very first date, he spent 45 minutes explaining to me his theories about Game of Thrones. Like, using Ned Stark as an example. Right? What do we know to start with? We know that he has a bastard. Right? He has John.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: But that's not true. He was hiding something so that he could protect a much bigger thing.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: We grow up with these characters over the extensive amounts of time it takes both to read the books and wait for them to come out, knowing that he is this flawed person, but then, we later know that the flaw is not that he had a child out of wedlock, but that he raised that child never to know their own heritage, which has, at that point, geopolitical implications. And those complexities are exactly the kind of thing that the report would seem to wish to excise. For example, again, this is very nerdy, so it's fine if you want to reorient a different section. I can do this for Star Trek, Star Wars.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: No. No. This is the interesting part of history. Right?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: It's because you have the good and bad that runs through all of us.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: And including through these great historical figures.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: Do you whitewash the bad in order to tell the good? If the answer is no, how much of the bad do you tell along with the good?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: And those are the debates that, in a certain sense, are playing out through the critiques that the White House is giving. They're coming down on kind of one extreme ideological side of it, but presumably, there are also the debates that are happening within the Smithsonian as they're creating any exhibit.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. And I think that there are open debates there. I will say, if you look at the intellectual history of this particular critique, it's not something the president ran on.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: It's not something that shows up in the Republican Party platform or the Democratic Party platform. It doesn't show up in Project 2025. The word Smithsonian appears nowhere in that document. The lead researcher at Heritage who's working on this wrote the Corporation for Public Broadcasting section at Project 2025. But that's where it's tempting to think these attacks in some way represent a portion of the right, or a portion of the libertarian movement, or a portion of the religious conservative movement. I challenge that.
I think that there is not that much support for going after the Smithsonian. If you look at the surveys that come out, if you look at the polling that goes out, this is a hobby of a couple of people at the White House that they're really upset about this, but when you look at the actual survey results of people, do they trust the Smithsonian? Do they want the White House in charge of how American history is portrayed? You don't get large numbers.
Nico Perrino: And the American history that they're concerned about is a very, very small fraction –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Uh-huh.
Nico Perrino: – of the total exhibits –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: – at the American History Museum.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: Am I not mistaken? I saw somewhere in your guys' response to that July 4th, 2026 report that it was like .00001% or something.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Exactly. We went through that report, our two amazing researchers, Justin Pullins and Marga Newell, and they went through and counted every object that was complained about. Most of that report is complaining about speech.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: It's complaining about the speech of people who work for the Smithsonian. That's the vast majority of the content. I don't want to misrepresent the report.
Nico Perrino: Okay. It's the speech of the people who work at the Smithsonian.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: That the report mostly complains about.
Nico Perrino: Not about what the public would actually see within the institution itself.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: The speech, and then, occasionally, the wall tags. They complain about the wall tags. Most of it's about the speech. Some of it's about the wall descriptions.
Nico Perrino: And some of these were exhibits or wall descriptions that are no longer there?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Most of them, actually.
Nico Perrino: Okay.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: There is no way to see for yourself and actually see the context of these, but when we went through the report, because if the claim and the subtitle of the White House Domestic Policy Council's report is that there has been ideological capture –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: – and if there had been. Right? Imagine this counterfactual. Imagine that the entire Smithsonian complex with its huge amounts of people and its vast diversity of both funding sources and organizations that are involved in it had been captured by one narrow particular way of thinking. You'd expect to see it on display. You'd expect to see it in the objects that were selected. They might pick objects to embarrass people or shame people, but when we went through, there were only 14 objects that were referenced in that whole 162-page report.
And of those 14, only seven are currently available for view at American History and ones at the Anacostia Community Museum. And there was a lot of mischaracterization of those objects. There’s a lot of listing and complaining about pictures of butterflies, because the White House Domestic Policy Council report argues that depictions of butterflies mean that the Smithsonian is supporting immigration reform. They use a very different term, but the way I would say it is immigration reform.
Nico Perrino: Do butterflies have something to do with immigration?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: They’re used sometimes for the DACA movement as like if you think about monarch butterflies migrate from Mexico. Right?
Nico Perrino: Oh. Okay. I didn’t know that. Now, I do.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Right. But they’re on the Virginia license plate, too. You can get the one with the pollinators on it.
Nico Perrino: Oh. Okay.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: They’re a symbol for the palliative care movement. But they made a list of places where butterflies existed, some of which reference immigration reform, some of which have no reference to it, and they included all of them –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Were they in butterfly exhibits or are they just –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: No. There’s a lot at American History.
Nico Perrino: They think this is like some sort of subtle psyop to get people to –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: They think it’s not subtle at all. They think –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Okay.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: – it’s the Smithsonian stating that the Smithsonian is a fan of immigration reform.
Nico Perrino: Okay.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: By including objects that refer to immigration reform.
Nico Perrino: Okay.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: If you look in the actual context, two of the images that they used, that they had pictures of in the report, have a butterfly and the word vote. And they lumped them in with other images of butterflies and say, “Oh. Well, look at this.” Except that those two, there’s an umbrella and a t-shirt; were from the 1970s.
Nico Perrino: Oh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Decades before this was a symbol.
Nico Perrino: Symbol for that cause.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Because that’s one of the peculiarities about this report that only came through when you really investigated it. Most of the objects they complain about are from the ‘70s and ‘80s, and then, closer to today.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: They weren’t able to highlight anything, any object that referred to the Revolutionary War period, or the Civil War period, not even World War II. The objects that they were complaining about are about things with in the lifetimes of the authors and within the lifetimes of many of the listeners here that they wish to control how that’s remembered.
Nico Perrino: How much of this is wrapped up in America’s 250th anniversary? Wasn’t the Smithsonian planning to do something big and grand for America 250? I know they did something, but weren’t they planning on doing some other things and that got all reworked once the Trump Administration came in and kinda scrapped the plans?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I mean, the Trump Administration took over the mall.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Which is usually where you would do some stuff if you want to do something big –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: – in this area.
Nico Perrino: Well, there was previously this bipartisan –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Uh-huh.
Nico Perrino: – congressional –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: – multiyear, I think, decade long –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: America 250.
Nico Perrino: – plan. Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. And then, Freedom 250, which is, I think, an LLC owned by the president’s colleagues.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And you see it all over D.C.
Nico Perrino: You do. Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Freedom 250. Even though it’s not actually the Congressionally-mandated one. Right.
Nico Perrino: Okay.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Which is very disturbing that that much money’s going into an LLC with no accountability.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. But I thought I read somewhere that, and I could be wrong that the Smithsonian was planning to do a big festival and some of that got scrapped.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: There’s usually the American Folklife Festival.
Nico Perrino: Okay.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: But they were forced to go into other locations because the White House took over the mall for the State Fair –
Nico Perrino: Okay.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: – exhibits, which we did document all of that, because we document as much as we can. Right? So that we can understand how these things are happening. And yeah. I think, so then, there were two different majors ways that 250th was celebrated at the Smithsonian that I’ve seen. I’ll do three, because there’s one that particularly exciting.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: The bonus one.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: It is. One is they made a collection of 250 objects. I think there was something from the Iraq War that’s, I think it’s a flack jacket. There’s like Thomas Jefferson’s writing desk. Just things that talk about the last 250 years.
Nico Perrino: That was in the castle. Right?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: That was in American History.
Nico Perrino: Okay.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: You kind of move your way through the building. It’s not all in one room. You have to actually traverse American History to see American history. Shocking, I know.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Okay.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And then, Secretary Bunch had put together a special exhibit in the castle that he curated himself of some really powerful objects.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. I remember seeing that one. I took my kids to that.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. And then, the third –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: And they were not very respectful of the object, so we got yelled at and had to leave. It was kind of dark in there. And that’s where I thought I saw –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. The [inaudible] [00:34:31].
Nico Perrino: – one of these signs, actually. Because Emily, our producer, was telling me that the signs haven’t gone up.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: No.
Nico Perrino: I swore I saw a sign somewhere that mentioned that the exhibits, or the signage that was in this or that room, was ideologically biased and has inaccuracies as known to the administration, but apparently, I am wrong because I’ve been told that none of it’s there, but I swear. I swear. It’s somewhere in the crevices of my memory.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Well, one of the –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: I thought I saw one of those.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Maybe you’re remembering –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Our listeners, if you’ve seen one of these –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: – please, please confirm it for me, because I thought I saw it somewhere at the mall.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. Please send it to us because we’re keeping a full archive of it.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: There are signs that have been put up around the national parks saying, “If you see anything on display here that is disparaging, please reach out through this QR code.”
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And if you look at the responses, it’s about 99.9% people swearing at the administration, or in other ways –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: [Inaudible – crosstalk] [00:35:23] responses are public?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yes.
Nico Perrino: Okay.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: They’ve been [inaudible], and so, you can see them, but they are either swearing at them or pointing out that they have no problem what the park services doing and would really like the White House to back off.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Like I said, there isn’t a movement. This isn’t a clash of ideological titans. This is a couple of folks have decided that this is their hobby horse and they happen to have a lot of power for the next 700-ish days and they wanna do it.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And I think that’s important, because there are so many pressures to treat everything as if it’s some easily [inaudible] battleground of ideologies in our country, but this isn’t. There actually is a major majority of Americans who want history to be determined through civil society, through big debates in public, not through somebody at the White House writing a report and people getting too scared to do their best work.
Nico Perrino: And signing executive orders with putting out signs in front of our museums saying that the museums of full of, you know, junk history or whatnot.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Which is why we’ve trained more than 100 volunteers to serve as volunteer docents, so as soon as the signs start going up, we’ll have our volunteers out. They’re prescheduled for shifts. Some will have scheduled for weekly shifts for months or years in advance. And they’ll be there with their little Citizens Historians for the Smithsonian buttons to answer people’s questions. If somebody goes up to the sign and I’m imagining what might be on the sign. Nobody knows what’s gonna be on them yet. If it’s lambasting some midlevel staffer for what they said.
The director of K-12 education at American History got an entire section written about him. And somebody’s sitting there going, “What is this?” Or the signs say, “Don’t go into this museum. Go to this other location, this other resource,” our volunteers will be there to start a civil conversation to offer the option of context and to mostly answer where the bathroom is, because that’s what we expect most people to ask. Right? Because this is like real life.
Nico Perrino: Sure. Well, in one sense, is this project that the White House has embarked on a good thing, because I mean, it’s prompted us to have a conversation about what history is, a good way of telling it, and ultimately, if the backlash to what the White House is doing garners more support for the Smithsonian, and its collections, and its project of preserving American history, that’s kind of the story of America in a certain sense, as Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg once said. When the pendulum swings too far in one direction, there’s often a backlash that pushes it in the other direction.
I do think these conversations, I mean, not that I’m endorsing what the administration is doing at all here. I mean, if anyone listens to this podcast, as they know, I’m a big process guy.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: And this administration has been like a bull in a China shop in going after institutions, but in doing so, it has also prompted conversations about how these institutions can most effectively operate.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I would say, at least for me, I would much rather these come from civil society. A lot of the work at these institutions, like a lot of the work in D.C., is done by folks in their 20s.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Who are interns, or who are contractors who don’t get paid when the government is shutdown, and they are living with a cloud of terror over them themselves about whether –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: They’re gonna get fired or be in a report.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Or publicly humiliated.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Or called names online, which of course, the president has a right to call people names online. It’s not my favorite behavior, but there’s, of course, as you talk about a lot, there’s an overlap between what when the government, particularly the White House, uses their power to chill speech or to frighten people. It chills their speech, and that is fundamentally undermining free-speech culture, which you guys talk about a lot.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I’ve gotten asked about what’s the impact of these two executive orders, and these letters, and this report, and these signs, because they haven’t done to the Smithsonian what they’ve done to the national parks. The real danger of all of these is that every museum professional in the world has read them.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And they live rent free in their heads.
Nico Perrino: And they’re getting the yips. I don’t know if we have any golfers listening to this, but there’s this phrase in golf where you get the yips. You know, you get a little bit nervous. You get a little bit scared. The pressures on. You know, people are watching you, for example, and your swing isn’t as smooth as [inaudible] [00:40:04], but your hesitating, and so, I imagine these curators or these museum professionals, as they’re trying to go about their job, they’ve got in the back of their head that there’s this microscope on them and that they could be a line in a 162-page report or a truth from the president.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Several pages worth.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Or yeah. And the thing is that this is an issue, interestingly, that not only divides a very small group of people who want the president to have control over the museums from the vast majority of Americans and people who don’t, but it’s caused some interesting debate within the Libertarian space, as well. Reason Magazine has run articles. Back in January, it was Alexandra Simpson, Senson, and then, Liz Wolfe have run articles arguing different sides. One, arguing the side, well, this is an important corrective to what’s been happening.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And the other, who’s an intern, who wrote it for Reason, saying, “It’s not furthering our goals to,” as in her case, “as libertarians to have the White House wanna be in charge of what is included in American history, but I guess one of my hopes is that this can be a moment of clarification for folks who feel very strongly about free speech and feel very strongly, and/or, because not all free-speech folks are libertarian folks. Right?
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And feel very strongly about that.
Nico Perrino: Civil Libertarian folks, probably.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I like to think so. I like to think so, but a moment of clarification of, like you said earlier, is there ever an excuse, an amount of power you can have that makes you wanna violate your principles of how free-speech culture should function?
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And I would argue, and I think a lot of people would argue, no. Even if you have the power, part of being in a democracy is using power wisely.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. Well, it’s interesting, too, because one of the core libertarian principles is that power can be abused.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Uh-huh.
Nico Perrino: And it should be diffused and there should be checks and balances that the enemy of liberty is power, and so –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: It’s [inaudible] [00:42:10] using it to squash disfavored speech. It’s not amazing.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I would argue it’s an anti-libertarian stance that people should think really carefully about before they, and I know how frustrating it is to have people pushing a narrative that you don’t feel comfortable with it. We’ve all lived through that in one part or another in our lives.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Well, that’s why I think this conversation is gonna resonate with some of our listeners, because one, they’re big fans of free speech, but I know some of them are also gonna write me and say, “Have you been to some of these places? Have you seen the focus on oppression and victimization?” It’s just gotten so tedious and ignores what I think should be the greater focus of this or that exhibit.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: I’ve seen that, as well. I mean, I lived in Philadelphia. I saw that site, George Washington’s old home when he was living there when that was the capital of the United States.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: And I was like, “There is kind of this overemphasis on the fact that he owned slaves.” Like, I understand the need to include it, but this is also the first president of the United States, capital of the United States, but that’s the debate. Right? That’s the debate that should be having amongst historians and amongst civil society, not one that should necessarily, as you’re saying, be decided by the president of the United States unilaterally.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. And I think about I’m always a funny one to talk about museums, because my grandma spent, she was an artist and a professor of life drawing, and she spent most of her career viciously attacking museums for not having enough women on the walls. Grandma could go after them. One of my very first jobs was transcribing decades of statistics she had put together about the ways in which women were not being included in any meaningful way in all these modern art museums.
And I think there’s so much that museums can do to better tell the American story, including any information about women. In many of these museums is novel.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: If you look at some of the exhibits that are much older, including any information about native peoples, or about the existence of slavery, or about the experiences of Latina people, or Asian-American people. It’s so novel that this is even here, and it is uncomfortable if folks have not grown up with those stories. Right? I understand there’s that discomfort, but it’s particularly disturbing to walk into a museum and not have anything to show my daughter.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. Well, museums aren’t unique in this respect. I mean, we’re also having this conversation about what should go in a library collection.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: I hear from listeners all the time about what I should be covering, but ultimately –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: – it’s a judgment call as to who I talk with and –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: – sometimes, they aren’t privy to all the reasons that I’ve framed a conversation a certain way or decided to go with this story as opposed to that. Sometimes, it’s –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: – basic and boring as the fact that I wanna have these conversations in person because they’re better conversations.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: And that means that people have to find their way to D.C. –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Uh-huh.
Nico Perrino: – at some point.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: Sometimes, we’ll be able to bring them in. Sometimes, we won’t.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: But there are a lot of reasons that might shape what goes into a collection, what goes into even an art exhibit.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Well, what’s kept.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. And what’s kept.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Right? That we were talking about before. If we don’t have objects representing women’s experiences, then, we can’t do a good job of it, or it’s really hard to. There’s an absolutely fantastic book called Mother Is a Verb, and it’s by Sarah Knott, who’s at Oxford now, and she used to be at University of Indiana.
Nico Perrino: Indiana University.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Indiana University. I’m so sorry.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Because I’m an alumnus.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I’m so sorry. Indiana University.
Nico Perrino: Oh. Well, there was this book written about D.C., I think, like a decade and a half ago –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: – called This Town.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Oh. Yeah. I’ve seen that one and it doesn’t have an index just to force everyone to actually read it.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. Well, in it, they refer to, because Indiana University has this famous kind of school of public affairs.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: And they refer to it as University of Indiana. I’m like, “No. It’s Indiana.” Very easy to do.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Frustrating. It’s very frustrating. I hear you.
Nico Perrino: But I guess Ohio State is also The Ohio State University.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: That’s fair.
Nico Perrino: I’d rather people get ours get wrong, or theirs wrong than ours wrong, because they’re just stupid.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I won’t get into the Buckeye versus thing, but.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: My wife is from Ohio.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Okay. That’s fair.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. My family has gone to Ohio State, a number of family members, so I can –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Well, and you’ll have this, because you have littles, too, but in this book, she tries to document the incredibly common experience of parents of being interrupted all the time.
Nico Perrino: Oh. Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: How would you go into the historical record to document getting interrupted all the time? She thinks about it, and thinks about it, and thinks about it, and she finds all of these diaries by mothers, or letters, where they had started writing and the line stops, and then, come back and say, “Oh my God. The baby needed me.” This is four hours later.
Nico Perrino: Oh. Wow.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And then, she just has this beautiful chapter, which I am interrupted all the time with two small children. Perhaps, yours are a little bit better about this than mine, but no.
Nico Perrino: No. No. No. My wife and share Instagram videos back and forth joking about how parents can’t have a 30-second conversation.
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Or 30-second thought.
Nico Perrino: Yeah. Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Right? And so, there are clever ways to put things into the record, or more correctly, to put things when you write it down as a historian, or when you make a display, to figure out how to express that. And there are ways to do it, but it’s so much easier to just document the things that people in power wanted.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Wouldn’t that be a little boring? Wouldn’t that be boring?
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Wouldn’t show you all the complexities of life.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. Or teach us how to handle difficult times, and I would say no matter how the elections go tomorrow, because of course, we’re doing this on the day before the midterms and we don’t know –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Yeah. This will come out, I think, the day after the midterms.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. And so, I think a lot of people feel like this is a difficult moment, and being able to look to our history and see not that it was easy for Thomas Jefferson or easy for George Washington, but how they managed their own flaws and complexities gives us the chance to figure out how to do it for ourselves.
Nico Perrino: Well, that’s one of the things that I was asked in, it was like a summer school course that I took in college.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: One of the prompts for one of the essays was could America have been founded if there wasn’t a compromise around slavery, and I think you have to put yourself in that period and honestly ask the question, as much as you might hate slavery. I had to say the answer was no. And now, is the world better off for having America and making that compromise around slavery? You know, those are difficult questions that we need to ask. I’d arguably say, probably, yes, but boy, is that a tough conclusion to come to.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Well, and –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Recognizing the challenges of the times.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And realizing. One of my professors says he’s been looking for angels in history for a long time and he’s never found them.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And that temptation to see things as good or bad, or things that happened and how did they happen, has been one of the, at least for me, one of the most freeing parts of graduate school. I tend to bring an activist mindset and I really wanna judge other people and what they did in the past.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And that is valuable, because you don’t wanna be just repeating errors that people made or horrors that they perpetuated. You also have to be able to take the judgment hat back off again and say, “How did they navigate this particular time and how could they have done better?”
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And what did they actually do? I was reading a lot about the revolution in Haiti and the ways in which people manage and mediated their own revolution, which did not keep slavery, and how they created their own version of what they wanted the 19th and 20th centuries to look like. And that’s an interesting counterfactual.
Nico Perrino: Uh-huh.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: What do you have if you take, so let’s say you have the non-slaveholding portions of the North, or you have the folks in the South. Do you end up with a successful [inaudible] [00:50:06] like Haiti? What if we had a Black Republic in the South?
Nico Perrino: Yeah. I was gonna say you might need to have multiple countries.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: If it was gonna work out.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: And so, could you have had the role that the United States plays in the world? Would we have been much more effective if we hadn’t the [inaudible] undermining us at every turn, which you can see in the record the British would just, even after they’re done fighting with us, the British and the French would just come back and say, “You’re saying all this stuff about liberty while someone who’s enslaved shines your shoes and warms your bed.”
Nico Perrino: Well, one of the things, I don’t know if you watched Tim Burns’s –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Not yet.
Nico Perrino: – the American Revolution documentary, which is fantastic and I’ve listened to him do a couple of interviews about it, and he said, “Slavery ended when Thomas Jefferson wrote those words, you know, we hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal,” because there was the seed of what was to come with the effort to end slavery and abolitionism in the Civil War, ultimately. It’s like America couldn’t live with that hypocrisy –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah.
Nico Perrino: – for too long.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: The house divided cannot stand.
Nico Perrino: A house divided cannot stand, and so, would we have had those words if the –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I think he could probably have written it while tying his own shoes.
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Finding a willing person for his own bed. I think those are –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: Yeah.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I don’t think there’s anything inherent in the document that required him to be using the labor of people he wasn’t paying. Right?
Nico Perrino: Didn’t his original draft say something about slavery, too?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I’m not a historian of that one.
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: I thought I read that somewhere that his original draft condemned slavery, but it was taken out, but I could be totally wrong on that. I thought that was something I read when I was doing my America 250 fix this past year, but let’s close up here –
[Crosstalk]
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Sure.
Nico Perrino: – by just kind of asking how we move forward. Is it possible to maintain the independence of public expressive institutions from political pressure, if they are created, managed, funded? Is there a universe, for example, where the Smithsonian could just go completely private? That would probably have to take an act of Congress.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Yeah. It would have to take an act of Congress. That is the argument that was made by Liz Wolfe in Reason, was to starve the beast. I think she wrote about that you should have, she named a couple of major donors on each side, and have them do gout and them decide what American history is. I think we would all lose something fundamental as Americans if there were not these great museums. There isn’t any other place in the world where you can walk in and see these 21 institutions and cover all this huge range. I would not want to see them –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: But theoretically, it could exist on its own. It would need an incredible amount of funding in order to remain free and open to the public like they are. Right?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I think people said the same thing about USAAD and there are between 700,000 and 800,000 people who will be dead in the next 10 years because everyone said, “Oh. The private sector will cover it,” but they can’t and they won’t. And I would say that –
[Crosstalk]
Nico Perrino: You think this is a unique institution, and it’s one that needs government funding, and that the American people get a benefit from that justifies that funding.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: I would argue that it is, and even when people might disagree with the materials that they put out, yeah. The article in Reason had this piece about that every libertarian can find something to hate in the Smithsonian. I think that’s true of every person. You can walk in, and if you want to find something to be upset about, you can. I think about that quote at the beginning of the White House Domestic Policy Council report where they said the people who work in this museum don’t want you to love your country, and I love my country like I love my kids.
I love it for all of its wildness, and all of its irascibility, and all of its complete randomness, and all of its brilliance, and love, and kindness, and glory, and all those things that you see when you’re raising littles. And I want these museums to show the value of consistency of showing up every day despite incredibly censorious pressures that they’re under right now from the White House. Showing up and continuing to do their best work.
And I’m hoping that if the institution, that is the Smithsonian, if every other museum that has faced budget cuts, every historian who’s had their grant canceled for having a word that the White House doesn’t like in their application, people are gonna need to look to something when they’re rebuilding, something that didn’t bend and didn’t break, and if that’s the Smithsonian that gives us a model for how to move forward.
I don’t think the American people are served by institutions that bend and break with every new occupant of the White House, and anybody who can imagine somebody other than this current president of the White House who they disagree with in that role, also does not want those. They don’t want weather vane institutions, but yeah. I would say that, fundamentally, this is an institution that was brought into being in 1846 by an act of Congress and it should keep doing the work that the American people are asking it to do.
And if we can remember that that is work that we care about, and that this is our history, and it’s our job to protect it, and that the first amendment is a use-it-or-lose-it right, I think we can make it forward and I think we can do this.
Nico Perrino: Well, I think that’s a good place to leave it. Jessica, thanks for coming on the show.
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Thank you so much for having me.
Nico Perrino: That was Jessica Dickenson Goodman from the Citizen Historians for the Smithsonian. Jessica, what’s the website for that?
Jessica Dickinson Goodman: Citizenhistorians.org.
Nico Perrino: Okay. Well, thank you for everything you’re doing and thank you for coming on the show. I am Nico Perrino and this podcast is recorded by rotating roster of my FIRE colleagues, including Bruce Jones, Ronald Baez, Jackson Fleagle, and Scott Rogers. The podcast is produced and edited by Emily Beeman. To learn more about So to Speak, you can subscribe to our YouTube channel or Substack page, both of which feature video versions of this conversation. We’re also on X by searching for the handle freespeechtalk. You can send us feedback at sotospeak@fire.org.
Again, that is sotospeak@fire.org. If you enjoyed this podcast, please leave us a review wherever you get your episodes, and until next time, thanks again for listening. The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, FIRE, and the flame logo are registered trademarks of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression.
[End of Audio]
Duration: 57 minutes