Table of Contents

Brief of Amici Curiae in Support of Appellant - Bean Maine Lobster, Inc., et al. v. Monterey Bay Aquarium Foundation

FIRE logo above a file with papers in it

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT

Defamation lawsuits based on statements about large groups run counter to the core principles of free expression embodied in the First Amendment. Authorizing such group-defamation actions would greatly expand the range of speech that is subject to civil liability and threaten citizens’ ability to speak out on issues of public concern. If allowed, such actions would require courts to assess the accuracy and impact of general statements about entire industries, professions, political movements, religious and cultural groups, and even national or ethnic communities. Defamation law would then encompass a vast universe of constitutionally protected speech, eroding the protections of the First Amendment.

For this reason, among others, courts have long rejected group-defamation claims, holding that a statement is actionable only if it is “of and concerning” a specific plaintiff. This rule prevents a plaintiff from attacking speech that does not directly impugn the plaintiff in particular, including speech addressed to matters of public concern. 

Here, trade associations representing over 5,600 Maine lobstermen sued the Monterey Bay Aquarium Foundation (MBAF), alleging MBAF made defamatory statements about the impact of the lobster industry on North Atlantic right whales. Plaintiffs do not allege MBAF said anything about particular companies or individuals; rather, all the statements at issue address the lobster industry as a whole. The district court denied MBAF’s motion to dismiss, holding that its general statements implied “each and every Maine lobsterman” endangers the right whale.

The district court acknowledged the general nature of MBAF’s statements, but held that the “circumstances of publication” reasonably suggested it was referring to each of thousands of lobstermen. While it is true that the circumstances of publication can, in some cases, transform a statement that is general on its face into one that references a specific plaintiff, the district court did not identify any such circumstances here. Instead, it held MBAF’s statements applied to every lobsterman because they addressed the entire industry, adopting reasoning that would apply to any blanket statement about a large group.

This Court should reverse the district court and hold that the First Amendment bars an individual — whether a person, a company, or an organization — from suing for defamation based upon statements about large groups or classes of people. Affirming the district court would set a dangerous precedent by allowing individual members of large, diffuse groups to attack political speech and other commentary about issues of public concern. The Constitution safeguards our freedom to discuss such topics without fearing we will be hauled into court. Defamation law is designed to redress concrete injuries to identified individuals; it must not become a tool to threaten public discourse and debate.

READ THE FULL AMICUS BRIEF BELOW

Share