Why does America protect hate speech? w/ Samantha Barbas

So to Speak: The Free Speech PodcastEp. 287
Why does America protect hate speech? w/ Samantha Barbas

Why does America protect hate speech? w/ Samantha Barbas

The First Amendment protects even some of the most offensive and hateful expression. But how America came to recognize those protections is a complicated story.

Joining us to discuss that history is Samantha Barbas, professor of law and Aliber Family Chair at Iowa University College of Law, and author of Hate Speech: The Legal and Cultural History of an American Dilemma.

We discuss the rise of American Nazi movements and the infamous Skokie controversy, how civil rights groups helped shape modern free speech protections, and whether counterspeech is enough to combat hatred today.

Timestamps:

00:00 Intro

02:00 Does the First Amendment protect hate speech?

06:18 The origins of hate speech regulation

10:00 The rise and fall of Father Coughlin

14:38 Regulating the FCC and broadcast media

16:39 New Jersey's anti-Nazi law

20:12 Counterargument: free speech can destroy democracy

28:46 The Nazi march in Skokie, Illinois

33:50 Public opinion and the push to regulate hate speech

36:20 How are hate speech codes working in other democracies?

38:00 Counterspeech as an alternative to censorship

42:03 Samantha's next book projects

44:32 Outro

Enjoy listening to the podcast? Donate to FIRE today and get exclusive content like member webinars, special episodes, and more.

If you became a FIRE Member through a donation to FIRE at fire.org and would like access to Substack's paid subscriber podcast feed, please email sotospeak@fire.org.

Recent Episodes

FIRE Reacts: Trump's media ban
Share