Table of Contents
FIRE SURVEY: Americans have little confidence in either party to protect free speech
- Only 9% of Americans are fully confident that the Democratic Party will protect their First Amendment rights, and 10% feel the same about the Republican Party
- 73% of Americans say free speech is headed in the wrong direction — and a majority of these agree that political polarization is a reason why
- 89% of “very liberal” Americans — and only 46% of “very conservative” Americans — say it’s very or extremely important to be able to loudly criticize the police
PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 18, 2026 — A majority of Americans say they have no confidence that President Donald Trump will protect their First Amendment rights, a new survey from the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression finds.
Americans’ faith that Trump would protect their free speech has steadily dwindled over the course of his second term, according to FIRE’s National Speech Index. Now 51% have no confidence he’ll protect their First Amendment rights. Neither major political party grades well, either: Only 26% of Americans have “quite a lot of confidence” or their “full confidence” that the Democratic Party will protect their First Amendment rights, and only a combined 22% said the same about Republicans.
“After watching the world’s most powerful man sue, defund, jawbone, deport, threaten, and investigate his critics for nearly two years, it’s understandable that most Americans fear that their speech could make them the target of Trump’s wrath,” said FIRE Chief Researcher Sean Stevens. “And Americans don’t feel like they can trust either of the two major political parties to protect their First Amendment rights. That’s a sad state of affairs for free speech.”
All told, a staggering 73% of Americans believe that when it comes to whether people are able to freely express their views, things in America are heading in the wrong direction.
But Americans sharply disagree on why that is. Of Americans who believe free speech is going in the wrong direction:
- 86% of self-identified “very liberal” and 87% of “liberal” respondents blame the current presidential administration, versus 24% of self-identified “conservative” and 8% of “very conservative” respondents;
- 67% of very liberal and 57% of liberal respondents blame surveillance technology like Flock cameras, versus 33% of conservative and 39% of very conservative respondents;
- Only 36% of very liberal and 28% of liberal respondents blame the climate for speech on college and university campuses, versus 52% of conservative and 53% of very conservative respondents;
- 80% of very liberal and 58% of liberal respondents blame treatment of protesters and protests, versus 23% of conservative and 16% of very conservative respondents.
A majority of these Americans across the political spectrum do agree on one thing: political polarization is hindering free speech.
“It’s encouraging that Americans on both sides of the aisle recognize that political polarization poses a threat to free speech,” said FIRE Research Fellow and Manager of Polling and Analytics Nathan Honeycutt. “Rather than siloing themselves in echo chambers, Americans would benefit greatly from engaging with others who think differently.”
The survey also found that clear majorities believe it is important for Americans to be able to loudly criticize the police, politicians, government officials, judges, public figures, and religious leaders. This right is of particular importance to very liberal Americans, 89% of whom find it very or extremely important to be able to loudly criticize the police.
The National Speech Index is a quarterly poll designed by FIRE and conducted by the Dartmouth Polarization Research Lab, to capture Americans’ views on freedom of speech and the First Amendment, and to track how Americans’ views change over time. The October 2026 National Speech Index sampled 1,000 Americans and was conducted from October 15-22, 2026. The survey’s margin of error is +/- 3%.
The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) is a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization dedicated to defending and sustaining the individual rights of all Americans to free speech and free thought — the most essential qualities of liberty. FIRE educates Americans about the importance of these inalienable rights, promotes a culture of respect for these rights, and provides the means to preserve them.
The Polarization Research Lab (PRL) is a nonpartisan collaboration between faculty at Dartmouth College, Stanford University and the University of Pennsylvania. Its mission is to monitor and understand the causes and consequences of partisan animosity, support for democratic norm violations, and support for partisan violence in the American Public. With open and transparent data, it provides an objective assessment of the health of American democracy.
CONTACT:
Jack Whitten, Communications Campaign Strategist, FIRE: 215-717-3473; media@fire.org
Recent Articles
Get the latest free speech news and analysis from FIRE.
After protesters drive Gregory Bovino offstage, Rutgers gets free speech right
VICTORY: Federal officials agree to end censorship of Facebook group and app reporting ICE activity
Mississippi’s capital settles free speech lawsuit, agrees to reform comment rules